Social Media

Why do people not comment on blogs? The psychology and historical reasons

why-people-do-not-comment-on-blogs-r1_2x1
Perplexing is that people can read something and not have anything to say. What are the historical and psychology causes?

At the dawn of democracy, listening was primarily an active activity. People would debate each other. A statement would be made, the listener would respond. Communication was interpersonal.

Peter Kreten states in his first draft review of the book “Listening Publics”:

[Kate] Lacey begins her case by defining listening as: “the active direction of the sense of hearing to discern meaning from sound…” (p. 22) She then focuses on how communication is interconnected with political practices through cultural practices. For centuries, groups of individuals would gather together to discuss new ideas and policies. This became an integral part in the development of democracy.

However with the rise of new technologies beginning in the Industrial Revolution, listening habits began to change. Phonographs, telegraphs, telephones, print, and radio began to give audiences more control over what and how they listened. For the first time, individuals could return to their homes and listen in private to news, information, or entertainment. People no longer needed to participate in public discussions in order to stay interconnected to the outside world. They were now able to get their information privately.

With the rise of the TV in the last half of the 20th century, Peter Kreten states in his second draft, “listening went from being viewed as an active activity to a passive one.”

Have readers of blogs become passive?

Nine possible causes why people don’t comments on blogs:

1) Laziness
Does the reader have thoughts, but is too lazy to share them?

2) Fear of ridicule
Does the reader have thoughts, but there’s some other barrier to sharing? Fear of ridicule?

3) The commenting system makes it too difficult
Blogger is definitely guilty of that.

4) No time to comment
Having no time is not an excuse. If you spend the time reading something, you can spend the time commenting. If someone is using the time excuse, there is some other reason at play.

5) The reader wants his/her comments to be more public
Since the majority of the public visits facebook and twitter instead of blogs, perhaps some readers don’t want their comments to buried on a site somewhere. Why spend the time writing a comment, when your friends won’t see it? Of course, the solution would be to simply share your comment on facebook or twitter–which many people do.

A couple years ago I believed this to be a cause behind the drop in comments on my creative blog, spudart.org. I switched the comments system from being a natively built-in to using Facebook’s comments. The comments box from Facebook has a checkbox that makes it super-easy to publish your comment to your profile. To this day, nobody uses it. The majority of peope who use the facebook comments box on spudart.org are one-time visitors from google.

6) The reader wants his/her comments to be private
In an ironic switch from point five where the comments aren’t seen by enough people, this reason flips to the other side where people don’t want their comments to be readily available to everyone on the internet. While that is certainly a safe approach, it’s also to live your life in a manner of seclusion.

7) Comments in general are seen to be the scum of the internet
Spend any time on Youtube and you’ll see how this is true. Many people spew toxic fumes over the internet without any real thought. However, we need to convince people that there are certain areas of the internet where thoughtful comments can be shared. Where respect for others is emphasized.

8) The reader thinks that the writer doesn’t want comments
Peter Kreten in his review:

According to Lacey, broadcasters began diminishing the importance of engaging their audiences because they believed people would not listen. “During the formative years of broadcasting, this passivity was understood by some as being imposed on the listener by the mass address that spoke to no-one as someone, and everyone as anyone, denying the possibility of active engagement, personal development or equality of response.” (p. 114)

9) Does the reader have no thoughts at all?
I don’t want to be that pessimistic, but there is something about the readers’s attitude. Perhaps Lacey is onto something with passive listening. People may just sit and listen without any sort of inclination to respond.

The medium influences how we think

Ten years ago I realized while commuting on the streets of Chicago that whatever you have in your hands will influence how you perceive and interact with your surroundings.

If you have a camera in your hand (not your pocket) while walking, you’ll be more likely to take photos. If you have a pen and pad of paper in your hands while walking, you’ll be more likely to write down notes. Whatever is in your hands will influence what you do.

Has the internet become a place where we don’t have something in our hands? The iphone and ipad’s keyboard certainly puts a barrier in place for responding. Who wants to tippy-tap out a long comment?–especially when there is a simply one-tap like button.

Desktop users shouldn’t have that barrier in place, for they have a keyboard at the ready. However, maybe people don’t see their keyboard as a place for creation. Maybe they see the computer solely as a screen and a mouse. Mouses are for clicking and moving on, not for giving a response.

The tools for how we listen truly shape how we communicate.

Can you think of more reasons why people don’t comment on blogs?
I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments or on your favorite social media channel. This blog post appears on Reddit, Twitter, and Google Plus.

, ,

Leave a Reply

8 Comments on "Why do people not comment on blogs? The psychology and historical reasons"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Matt Maldre
Guest

In this blog post I mention Peter Kreten’s drafts of a book review. Today he finished the final book review and submitted it to Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media. If you’d like to read the final review (it’s quite good), you can see it on his blog at: http://pkreten.blogspot.com/2014/01/it-is-finished.html

(Also, Peter Kreten is my cousin. I don’t think I mentioned that yet)

bodacious75
Guest

Excellent. Comments, for me, invoke swill or non-comment. Or else my responses take too much time to craft if they are to be thoughtful. Really insightful on the digression of truly public discourse. Thanks for sharing.

Matt Maldre
Guest
Thanks Bruce! True, sometimes comments can often be really base–especially on youtube and mass media articles. And you bring up a good point about it taking too much time to craft. But as a reader, the value I get from leaving comments on someone else’s blog is that I can use that kernel of thought in my comment to generate a longer form blog post on my blog. This particular blog post is a case example of that. I was reading my cousin’s blog, which brought up many good points. I left a few comments on his blog posts, and… Read more »
Marco Buscaglia
Guest
For me, I think it’s a little of 4 and 5. Usually when I want to respond, I know I want to think it through for a bit and come up with something worthy of the post, so I plan on coming back to it later but usually don’t. In the instances when I do respond, I used to think about the possibility of putting something on someone else’s site or blog that I could put on my own. But I’m over that now. If anything, I’m much more appreciative of the ideas and starting points I get from you… Read more »
wilforbis
Guest
Let me first note the irony that this is the first article I’ve commented on in a while – perhaps years. Why so? I think posting a meaningful comment—more than just “I agree” or vice versa—does take a decent chunk of time. I can read most articles in a minute or three, but writing a thoughtful and errorless comment can take many times that. I also think many comments seem to be people seeking some kind of validation – “Look at me! Recognize my opinion!” It’s taken my 40+ years but I’ve just gotten over that sort of thing. I’ve… Read more »
Scot Duke
Guest

My blog viewers tell me they don’t comment due to them not wanting to receive notices on other people’s comments. Not sure there is a solution to that problem.

trackback

[…] Why People Do Not Comment on Blogs has a number of good reasons why people do not comment, but what are some solutions to eliminating the problems people have with commenting on blogs.  Maybe you have a few solutions we need to hear about..but that would require you to comment.  Hope you make an exception this time. […]

Savas Papadopoulos
Guest

Interesting article! What are you thoughts on the opposite question: why do people comment on blogs, news stories, forums, etc. I would be interested to hear your opinion / read your perspectives given your syndication experience

wpDiscuz